Are Aged Insurance Leads Worth Buying? What the Close Data Says by Age Band

GOAT Leads: Are aged insurance leads worth buying, close data by age band

Aged leads are worth buying for some agents and a waste of money for others. The split is about how you work, not about the leads. I've pulled our own numbers by age band. More than seven in ten agents who bought 20 or more aged leads in a band recorded no sale from them in the first 30 days. The agents at the top of each band did far better. That's the whole story.

Key takeaways

  • Sale rates fall as the age band gets older: the top quarter of agents recorded about 2.0% in 45-90 days and about 0.6% at 181+ days.
  • Most agents who buy 20 or more aged leads in a band record no sale in the first 30 days. Aged is a volume and follow-up game.
  • Aged leads are not exclusive. Treat every one as someone who may already have heard from an agent.
  • Buy aged if you have a dialer or AI dialer, a text cadence and the time to work a list. Skip it if you want a few warm conversations a day from fresh leads.

What is an aged insurance lead?

An aged insurance lead is a prospect who filled out a form at least 45 days ago. It's offered at a lower price. At GOAT Leads, aged leads sit in four age bands: 45-90, 91-120, 121-180 and 181+ days. The band sets the price. Older costs less.

Aged is different from fresh. A fresh lead goes to one agent only. That's what we mean by exclusive while fresh. After 45 days that lead can be sold as aged. If you want the full breakdown of the three types, I wrote it up in exclusive vs shared vs aged insurance leads.

Are aged leads exclusive?

No. Aged leads aren't exclusive. Treat every aged lead as someone who may already have heard from an agent, and open with a reason to talk today.

How often do aged leads turn into sales?

Less often than fresh leads, and less often the older the band. Here's what agents on our platform recorded, on a cohort basis (agents who bought at least 20 aged leads in that band):

Age band Agents in cohort Top 25% of agents Top 10% of agents Agents with at least one sale
45-90 days 1,700+ 2.0% 3.3% 29%
91-120 days 890+ 1.4% 2.6% 21%
121-180 days 1,300+ 1.0% 1.9% 21%
181+ days 2,500+ 0.6% 1.1% 27%

Read the columns as sales per lead delivered. A 2.0% rate in the top 25% column means those agents averaged about 2 recorded sales for every 100 aged leads. The median agent in every band recorded zero sales in the window, which tells you that these numbers belong to a minority who work aged leads hard.

Two things stand out. The best agents in the 45-90 band close roughly three times the rate of the best agents at 181+. And the 181+ band still produces sales for more than a quarter of agents. My guess is the lower price lets volume carry it.

Are aged leads worth it at the price?

They are worth it when your sales per hundred leads, times your average commission, clears what you paid by a wide margin. The math is yours to run, so here is how I run it.

Take a band, pick the rate that matches how you really work, and multiply. If you are in the top quarter at 181+ and you get about 0.6 sales per 100 leads, then 100 leads need to produce enough commission to beat 100 times the lead price. If you are an average agent who records no sales in 30 days, the same 100 leads cost you the full price and return nothing yet.

The store lists current prices by lead type and band, for example Final Expense and IUL on the aged leads store. Prices differ by type and band, so check the live page before you run the numbers.

Who should buy aged leads, and who should skip them?

Buy aged leads if you can touch a lot of people fast and keep touching them. That means a dialer or an AI dialer, a text and voicemail cadence over a couple of weeks, and a CRM that logs every attempt. Agents who work this way treat aged leads like a list and measure by the hundred.

Skip aged leads, for now, if you want one-call conversations from people who just asked for a quote. That is what fresh leads are for. If you are new and have no follow-up system, start with a small order in the 45-90 band, because it has the highest sale rates in our data and the person asked most recently.

Your situation Best band to start with
New agent, small budget, no dialer 45-90 days, small order
Working with a dialer or AI dialer 45-90 or 91-120 days
High volume, strong text cadence 121-180 or 181+ days
Want exclusive, first-call leads Fresh, not aged

What should you check before you buy aged leads?

Check three things: how old the lead is, what the replacement rules cover, and whether consent was captured. Ask each vendor for the answers in writing.

On our side, the age band is stated up front. Eligible problems such as duplicates can be flagged under the lead replacement policy. Replacement doesn't cover people who simply do not answer. Your own outreach still has to follow calling and texting rules, including the TCPA and Do-Not-Call laws. If you want a lead with more consent detail, read about Standard+ insurance leads.

How we measured this

We counted aged leads delivered from August 1 to October 19, 2026. That gives every lead at least 30 days to produce a sale. A lead counts as sold when the agent recorded a policy sale in the CRM, or a sold date on the lead, within 30 days of delivery. Replacement copies and test leads are excluded.

We grouped leads by agent and by age band. We kept agents with 20 or more aged leads in that band, and ranked them by sale rate. Top 25% and top 10% are the average sale rate of the best-performing agents in each band, ranked by that same rate. They show what strong results look like and not what to expect. With 20 or more leads per agent, a few lucky sales can lift an agent into the top group. The numbers are CRM-reported, so they are conservative. Agents who sell and forget to log it are counted as zero. A sale that closes after day 30 doesn't show up in this window, so treat these as early rates. Agents can appear in more than one band.

FAQ

Is aged worth it for final expense?

They can be because the lead price is low and final expense agents often work lists by phone. Start in the 45-90 band. Call and text every lead. Count sales per hundred before you order more. Final expense is among our lowest priced lead types, which is why agents run it in volume.

Is it better to buy fresh or aged leads?

Fresh leads cost more and go to one agent only. Aged leads cost less and take more attempts. Plenty of agents run both. Fresh leads get the same-day calls and aged leads can fill the gaps in the afternoon.

Which age band should I buy first?

Start in 45-90 days. In our data it has the highest sale rates, and the person asked most recently.

Can I get a replacement on an aged lead?

Eligible problems, such as disconnected numbers and duplicates, can be flagged under the lead replacement policy. Unresponsive numbers are not covered. The policy page lists exactly what qualifies, so read it first.

What consent record comes with an aged lead?

Don't assume there is one. Ask your vendor what consent record exists for the exact band and type you're buying. Standard+ leads include a TrustedForm certificate, and aged leads should be treated as needing your own outreach compliance.

Run a 30 day test

Start small.

Order one band. Work every lead. Count your sales per hundred leads after 30 days.

That number tells you more than anything I can write here. Browse the aged leads store.

Ready to grow your book of business?

Fresh, real-time final expense, veteran and trucker leads delivered straight to your CRM.

Get Leads